Friday, February 20, 2009

Bookmarks: Some stuff to read on the internet: Bono and Bob

G2 meets Dambisa Moyo, who provides one of the sharpest critiques of what's wrong with Bono I've read in a while:

Partly, of course, it's about power, and purse-strings; partly, she believes, it's a PR issue, "there are many well-spoken, smart African leaders who should be on the global stage"; very largely, given that so far not many are, it's a case of who gets to do the talking, and increasingly, it is people like Bob Geldof and Bono, the most visible representatives of what she calls, in a thrillingly withering manner, "glamour aid".

"There are African policymakers who are charged with the responsibility of creating policy, and implementing policy. That's their job. Long, long lines of people have stood in the sun to vote for a president who is effectively impotent because of donors or because glamour aid has decided to speak on behalf of a continent.

How would British people feel if tomorrow Michael Jackson started telling them how they should get out of the housing crisis? Or if Amy Winehouse started to give the US government advice about the credit crunch? And was listened to? I think they would be perturbed, and worried. I mean, they've completely disenfranchised the very people we've actually elected!"


3 comments:

Paul Wells said...

Its an interesting interview but you can't avoid the sad fact that far, far more people listen in the west when Bono or Bob speak compared to if it was a 'well-spoken, smart African leader'. Calling it glamour aid in a 'thrillingly withering manner' may let her take the moral high ground but these days nothing is noticed without a celebrity endorsement attached to it at the top with a paper-clip.

Simon Hayes Budgen said...

Fair point, Paul - but then you could ask "why doesn't Bono appear with an African politician rather than George W Bush, or a photogenic African baby?"

Anonymous said...

Paul, I think you may be confusing "nothing is noticed without a celebrity endorsement" with "nothing is given a high profile by the media without a celebrity endorsement".

Post a Comment

As a general rule, posts will only be deleted if they reek of spam.