Thursday, June 18, 2009

Amazon try to monetize IMDB

Interesting email from Lucy B:

Admittedly this has nothing much to do with music I'm afraid, but it is about the way some of the biggest entertainment websites show the same ruthless imperial tendencies as the giant corporate behemoths of the 'old days'.

The Internet Movie Database (IMDB) was, and mostly still is, a huge free information resource about movies and TV which is much loved by its users.

But lo, what happens all of a sudden if you try and 'register' on the IMDB so that you can post messages to its apparently free and independent messageboard? It turns out 'registering' is only a first step which gives you no useful access rights whatsoever. In order to register in the sense of being able to post messages, you have to either give your amazon user account details (eh?) or provide a credit card number (what????) so that the IMDB can 'verify' your account.

I presume this means 'verify' in the sense of 'either force IMDB's users to sign up for Amazon accounts or make them give financial details over the internet, all for a service which is supposed to be free' which is a usage of the word I hadn't come across before.

Where's the need to 'verify' people anyway? This isn't Ebay and the IMDB's users want to write ill-spelt messages about who they think should have played Captain Kirk in the new Star Trek, not sell knocked-off Ipods to each other.

I'm saddened by all this - suddenly the IMDB, which was such a democratic and spirited entity, has become a front for something altogether more commercial. I'm even saddened by Amazon, which I previously had thought was astute, but not underhand.

What's perhaps even more galling is that, even if you do hand over this information, your "registered" account will still see you stuck with what Amazon call a "posting quota" but is actually an enforced delay between posts of anything up to a couple of minutes. If you want no quota at all... well, you can hand over some cash for a 'pro' account.


3 comments:

Harold said...

Lucy B appears to have missed the other option, by the way - you can use your mobile phone number to register instead. It's basically a way of stopping trolls constantly re-registering.

Anonymous said...

It's been like that for years - like Harold says, an anti troll measure I think ... the troll problem has got better since, anyhow.

Bluesman said...

Posting off topic, trolling for arguments and other misuses of the message boards will get your posts deleted and your posting quota raised. If you misbehave on IMDb's site, you can expect the admins to action your account. A raised quota is only a mild punishment. Your posting history can be erased, and in the most extreme cases, your posting privileges can be revoked.

Post a Comment

As a general rule, posts will only be deleted if they reek of spam.

Post a Comment